NOTE: As of 2022 the Center for Executive Coaching is now accredited with the ICF as a Level 2 Coach Training Organization. The ICF has changed their language and replaced ACTP with Level 2. We were among the first group of coach training programs to receive this accreditation, after a rigorous review by the ICF.

12 Angry Men and Executive Coaching

Have you seen the movie Twelve Angry Men? If you are a coach, you absolutely must.

I saw the movie a long time ago, and just saw it performed as a play at the Asolo Theater here in Sarasota, Florida.

In it, 12 jurors must deliberate on what seems like an open-and-shut murder case. The initial vote is 11 jurors for a guilty verdicts and one for a not guilty verdict. The 11 jurors are furious. They have things to do, including one juror who has tickets to a baseball game.

The play is about how the 12th juror holds his ground and gradually sways each and every other juror.

It is an incredible case study about how to influence people, how to take a stand, and how to use what leverage one has to do the right thing.

At first, the 12th juror uses his "not guilty" vote to make sure that there is enough discussion before convicting the defendant. He admits that he doesn't know whether they defendant is guilty or not, but wants to talk about it. He believes that every defendant deserves that right, especially when a death sentence is required in case of a guilty verdict.

The jurors are furious at him, because they think the case is clear — especially when the 12th juror admits that the defendant might be guilty or might not be.

Now the 12th juror uses the form of influence known as negotiating. He says, "Let's just talk for an hour. If you all still vote guilty after that hour, I'll go along with you."

From there, he raises each and every piece of evidence, and uses facts and logic to systematically dismantle the prosecution's case.

But he does more than that. With each and every fact, he convinces just one more juror that there is a shadow of a doubt. He creates a growign coalition of jurors on his side, who start to persuade other jurors. 

By the end, only a few bigoted or highly biased jurors remain, and it takes the large coalition of jurors to stand up for the defendant and overcome their emotional, irrational attachment to a guilty verdict.

The Center for Executive Coaching has some excellent content on coaching clients to become more influential. This includes the types of conversations that influence others, as well as how to get an idea accepted in a politically charged organization, and how to build one's power base over time. At the same time, if you haven't seen Twelve Angry Men, get it today!

Aflac

Amazon

Ancestry

Army Corp of Engineers

Ascension Health

AT&T

Bank of America

Bechtel

Best Buy

Booz Allen

Bose

Bristol-Myers Squibb

Brown University

Capital One

Caterpillar

Charles Schwab & Co.

Children’s Hospital Colorado

Cisco

Citrix

Coca-Cola

Deloitte

Dropbox

Duke Energy

Galveston Independent School District

General Atomics

General Electric

Google

Harvard Business School

Home Depot

Inland Steel

International Red Cross

Johnson and Johnson

Kaiser-Permanente

KPMG

Laser Spine Institute

Lexis Nexis

Liberty Mututal

L’Oreal

Macy’s

Mckinsey Consulting

Merck

Microsoft

MIT

NASA

National Basketball Association (NBA)

Nike

Nissan

Nvidia

Partners Healthcare

Philips

Procter & Gamble

Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC)

Ralph Lauren

Regeneron

Rice University

Ross Stores

Russell Reynolds Associates

Schneider Electric

Shell Oil

SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory

Stryker

The Ohio State University

Tom’s Shoes

United Nations

University of Florida

Unum

UPS

US Air Force

US Army

US Army Medical Corps

US Marines

US Navy

USAID

Valassis

VMWare

Xerox

Zappos

Our featured articles